Will 2020 be the year that censured ICOs sue their advising law firms? If the action against Faegre Baker Daniels is any indication, the answer is “yes.” But do these cases have merit?
ICO Suing Advising Law Firm
Digital Capital Management, which developed a cryptocurrency investing fund called Crypto Asset Management, is suing international law firm Faegre Baker Daniels for allegedly administering “questionable advice.” According to the complaint, Faegre Baker Daniels supposedly steered the fund away from registering with the Securities and Exchange Commission — as stipulated under the Investment Adviser Act of 1940 — because its structure didn’t constitute a security. The SEC disagreed, and in 2018 slapped the fund with an enforcement action and $200,000 fine for failing to register despite qualifying as an “investment company.” Now, the finance firm is pointing a finger at its law firm for counseling that cryptocurrency assets weren’t securities.
Are Cryptocurrencies Securities?
The suit’s gravamen is whether or not Digital Capital Management’s product qualifies as a security. Unfortunately, the answer isn’t crystal clear. Some crypto ventures do fall under the securities umbrella; others don’t. Judges use “the Howey Test” to make the determination.
What is the Howey Test?
Developed for a Supreme Court case (SEC v. W.J. Howey Co.) involving a 1940s orange grove opportunity, the Howey test examines four elements of a financial product to determine whether or not its a security. The Howey Test defines an investment contract as one where a party:
In a common enterprise,
With the expectation of profiting,
Based on the efforts of a third party.
Will these Lawsuits Against ICO Law Firms Succeed?
Do you have legal questions about an ICO? Our cryptocurrency legal team is ready to answer. We’ve been involved with digital currency law since the early days and have successfully ushered several ICOs through the SEC and IRS maze. Get in touch today and discover why our clients rate us 10 out of 10 on respected lawyer review platform, AVVO.com.
Ethereum 2.0 Tax Guide
How is Ethereum 2.0 taxed? Our cryptocurrency tax attorneys dive into the tricky questions.
The Supreme Court of illinois does not recognize certifications of specialties in the practice of law and the certificate, awardor recognition is not a requirement to practice law in illinois. The information on this website is for general purpose only and should not be intercepted to indicate a certain result will occur in your specific legal situation.The information on this website is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship.